Only 5 spots every week!
Book your Free Sales Audit today before spots are gone.

The 5 Conversion Killers Lurking on Every Shopify Store (and How to Fix Them Before Black Friday)

Most eCommerce stores don’t need more traffic — they need to stop losing sales. Here are the 5 most common conversion killers we uncover in Shopify audits and exactly how to fix them.

The Real Reason Your Shopify Store Isn’t Converting (and It’s Not Your Ads)

You can have the best ads, the right products, and endless traffic — but if your store leaks conversions, you’ll always feel stuck.

At Sales Leak Labs, after auditing hundreds of Shopify stores, we’ve found that almost 80% of lost revenue comes from just five small mistakes that repeat over and over.

These leaks aren’t obvious until you fix them — and then your store finally starts converting like it should.

Let’s break down the top 5 conversion killers, what they look like in real life, and how to eliminate them for good.

1. Product Descriptions That Either Bore or Confuse

What We See

Two extremes — and both cost you sales.

The “Specs Only” type:

“100% cotton. Set of 5. Machine washable.”

Technically correct, emotionally dead.

The “Artsy-Fartsy” type:

“Feels like sleeping on a cloud while sheep count themselves.”

Lovely imagery — but no info to confirm the purchase.

Why It Kills Conversions

Shoppers need both emotion and logic to buy.

If you only sell the feeling, they doubt the quality.

If you only sell the facts, they feel nothing.

The Fix

Lead with emotion — paint the picture, describe the transformation — then close with facts.

“Sink into ultra-soft, 100% cotton sheets that stay cool and smooth all night long. Set of 5, machine washable, and made to outlast every season.”

If possible, use separate tabs for “Description” and “Specifications.”
If not, lead with benefits, end with details.

Example product page hierarchy from Marks & Spencer website

Pro tip:  Add icons or bullets for specs — visual hierarchy builds trust fast.

You’re spending on ads, but sales aren’t moving

Sales don’t match the effort. Before you spend another pound on ads, grab the Sales Leak Checklist. Find the silent killers hiding in your store and plug them fast.

2. Hidden or Confusing Delivery Costs

What We See

Stores that hide delivery pricing until checkout.

Worse — those that surprise customers with extra fees.

Why It Kills Conversions

Unexpected costs are the #1 reason for cart abandonment (Shopify’s own data backs this up).

When people don’t know what they’ll pay, they bounce.

The Fix

Be upfront. Always.

If your delivery prices vary, show:

“Delivery from £3.99”
or even better,
“Free delivery from £50.”

The second one doesn’t just convert better — it raises AOV because customers intentionally add more to hit that free shipping threshold.

Example from Garden 4 Less: they show estimates and delivery options already on product pages. Whilst it might be an overkill for some stores, it definitely helps customers to plan better.

Pro tip:  If you offer free delivery — say it everywhere: header bar, product page, cart.
You paid to get the click; don’t lose it to a hidden £4.99 at checkout.

3. Slow Load Speeds and Heavy Images

What We See

Beautiful designs that take 10 seconds to load.

Every second after 3 drops conversion by 7%.

Why It Kills Conversions:

Your visitor’s brain connects “slow site” with “unreliable store.”

Mobile shoppers (60–80% of your traffic) won’t wait.

The Fix

  • Compress images (WebP or AVIF).
  • Minimize apps — most add scripts that slow load times.
  • Test speed regularly on Google PageSpeed + GTmetrix.

Pro tip:  A faster store not only converts better — it ranks higher in Google.

4. Weak or Missing Social Proof

What We See

No reviews, no UGC, no credibility signals.

Why It Kills Conversions

In eCommerce, belief converts more than design.

If a shopper has never heard of you, they buy because others already did.

The Fix

  • Add photo reviews, not just text.
  • Use short, story-style testimonials: “Before → After.”
  • Feature press mentions or badges (“Seen in…”, “Trusted by 10,000+ customers”).

Example from Maple Gifts product page: they show pickup option, free delivery threshold, payment options and even a preview of reviews.

Pro tip:  Place reviews under the Add to Cart button — not hidden in a separate tab.

See exactly where your store leaks money

We’ll personally record a 10-minute video showing the top 3 leaks stopping your sales — and how to fix them. No pitch. No fluff. Just actionable proof.

5. Weak or Nonexistent Value Proposition Above the Fold

What We See

Hero sections that say things like “Welcome to [Brand]” — zero relevance, zero clarity.

Why It Kills Conversions

If users can’t tell what you sell or why it’s different in 3 seconds, they leave.

The Fix

Above the fold, always answer:

  • What it is
  • Who it’s for
  • Why it’s better

Example:

“Luxury bed linen for people who hate overpriced hotels. 100% cotton, ethically made, shipped free from the UK.”

Example from Emma Sleep website: Black Friday offers right away, shows looped mattress video, clear CTA and trust signals (logos and 'Most trusted brand in UK')

Stop Losing Shopify Sales to Fixable Conversion Leaks

Most Shopify founders think they need more traffic — but in 9 out of 10 audits, we find it’s not a traffic problem at all.

It’s the leaks inside the store that silently kill sales every single day.

Slow pages, vague copy, hidden delivery costs, no proof, weak offers — these are not “minor” issues.

They’re the difference between a £10K and a £50K month.

When you fix them, everything starts compounding:

  • Ads perform better because they lead to pages that actually convert.
  • AOV rises because customers trust what they’re buying.
  • ROAS improves because you’re no longer paying for clicks that bounce.

And the best part?

You already have the traffic — you just need to turn it into revenue.

That’s exactly what we do at Sales Leak Labs.

We audit your store, uncover the leaks, and rebuild your systems so every visit, ad, and checkout works harder for you.

Whether you start with our free 10-minute audit video or go all-in with the 90-Day Accelerator, this is your moment to stop guessing and start scaling.

Don’t let another week of sales slip through invisible cracks.

The Proven System Behind Sales Leak Labs’ Top Performers

This is the exact process we use to grow our portfolio stores — refined across hundreds of audits and millions in tracked revenue.

Published on
Tuesday, November 4, 2025
and written by
Margarita Sibilkina
Author
Margarita Sibilkina
Founder & eCommerce Specialist
Founder of Sales Leak Labs, Margarita Sibilkina has audited hundreds of Shopify stores to uncover why traffic doesn’t always mean sales. Her work helps brands fix conversion leaks and scale without burning ad spend.

The 5 Conversion Killers Lurking on Every Shopify Store (and How to Fix Them Before Black Friday)

Most eCommerce stores don’t need more traffic — they need to stop losing sales. Here are the 5 most common conversion killers we uncover in Shopify audits and exactly how to fix them.
Read post

How to Increase AOV Without Raising Prices

Your ad spend is rising, but profits aren’t. The fix isn’t higher prices — it’s smarter offers. Here’s how to boost your Average Order Value using proven psychological triggers and store tactics that make customers happily spend more.
Read post

Why Your Ads Are Working — But Your Store Isn’t

If your Facebook or Google Ads are driving traffic but your Shopify store isn’t converting, you don’t have a traffic problem — you have a conversion leak. Here’s how to find it, fix it, and finally make your ad spend pay off.
Read post